Festive Christmas cookie cutters and dough on a wooden countertop

The Best Christmas Cookie Cutters for Festive Holiday Baking

by

The holiday season is all about warmth, togetherness, and of course, delicious Christmas cookies! Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just starting out, the right Christmas cookie cutters can make your treats extra festive. From classic shapes like Santa and reindeer to trendy 3D designs, these little tools add charm and creativity to your holiday baking.

But cookie cutters aren’t just about shapes! Choosing the right material, using them properly, and decorating your cookies with flair can take your baking to the next level. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know about Christmas cookie cutters—from the best ones to buy, how to use them effectively, and even some fun DIY ideas.

Let’s dive into the magic of holiday baking and explore how you can create picture-perfect cookies with the best cutters this season!

Christmas cookie cutters are specially designed tools that help shape cookie dough into festive forms. They come in various materials like stainless steel, plastic, and silicone, allowing bakers to create themed treats for the holidays. These cutters can be simple outlines or detailed molds that imprint designs directly onto the cookie surface.

Using cookie cutters for holiday baking isn’t just about making cookies look pretty; it’s a fun tradition that brings families and friends together. Whether you’re making gingerbread men, Christmas trees, or intricate snowflakes, these cutters make the process effortless and enjoyable.

Why They Are Essential for Holiday Baking

There’s nothing quite like a plate of beautifully shaped, decorated cookies at a holiday gathering. Christmas cookie cutters help achieve that perfect festive touch. Here’s why they’re a must-have:

  • Creativity & Fun – Kids and adults alike love cutting out fun shapes and decorating them.
  • Time-Saving – Instead of shaping cookies by hand, cutters help create uniform pieces quickly.
  • Perfect for Gifting – Homemade Christmas cookies in fun shapes make for heartwarming gifts.
  • Versatile Uses – Beyond cookies, they can be used for fondant, crafts, and even sandwiches!

Cookie cutters date back centuries, with early versions appearing in Germany and the Netherlands. These countries are famous for intricately designed gingerbread cookies, which were often cut into festive shapes using wooden molds or tin cutters. When German immigrants brought their baking traditions to America, Christmas cookie cutters became a staple in holiday kitchens.

By the 19th century, tin cookie cutters became widely available, allowing home bakers to create seasonal cookies more easily. Today, you’ll find cutters in an endless variety of shapes, sizes, and materials, making it simple to add a personalized touch to holiday baking.

Christmas cookie cutters bring a special kind of holiday cheer to the kitchen. Whether you’re baking for fun, family, or a festive party, these essential tools make it easy to create beautiful and delicious holiday treats.

Types of Christmas Cookie Cutters

When it comes to baking the perfect holiday cookies, choosing the right Christmas cookie cutters is essential. Not all cutters are created equal, and the type you use can impact everything from precision to ease of use and durability. Let’s take a closer look at the different types available and how to pick the best one for your needs.

Metal vs. Plastic: Which Is Better?

The debate between metal and plastic cookie cutters is ongoing, but each has its own strengths:

  • Metal Cookie Cutters: Typically made from stainless steel or tin, metal cutters provide sharp edges, ensuring clean and precise cuts. They’re durable and work well with firm cookie doughs like gingerbread and sugar cookies. However, they may bend over time and require proper storage to prevent rusting.
  • Plastic Cookie Cutters: These are often lightweight, colorful, and kid-friendly. They come in more detailed shapes since they are molded, making them great for fun holiday designs. However, they might not cut through dense dough as easily as metal ones.

Nothing says Christmas like festive-shaped cookies! Here are some of the most popular themed Christmas cookie cutters:

  • Santa Claus & Elves – Perfect for traditional holiday baking.
  • Reindeer & Sleighs – Fun shapes that kids love decorating.
  • Snowflakes & Stars – Ideal for elegant, frosted sugar cookies.
  • Christmas Trees & Wreaths – Classic and easy to decorate.
  • Gingerbread Men & Candy Canes – Timeless choices for festive treats.

Themed cookie cutters are available in single pieces or multi-set packs, making them perfect for baking a variety of holiday cookies.

For those who love to get creative, 3D cookie cutters bring a whole new dimension to holiday baking! These cutters allow you to create cookies that stand upright, forming edible Christmas decorations. Popular designs include:

  • Gingerbread houses
  • Christmas tree structures
  • Reindeer figurines

Although they take a bit more effort, 3D cookies add an impressive touch to holiday desserts.

Want something truly unique? Custom cookie cutters allow bakers to create cookies shaped like names, logos, or custom holiday messages. Many online stores, including Etsy and Amazon, offer personalized options for those looking to make one-of-a-kind treats.

Picking the right Christmas cookie cutters depends on your baking style, desired shapes, and level of experience. Whether you prefer metal for durability, plastic for ease, or customized designs for creativity, the right cutters will make your holiday baking even more festive!

Best Christmas Cookie Cutters to Buy in 2025

Various Christmas cookie cutters arranged on a marble surface
A collection of festive cookie cutters, ready for holiday baking

Finding the best Christmas cookie cutters can make holiday baking fun, easy, and stress-free. Whether you’re looking for high-quality materials, budget-friendly options, or unique designs, we’ve rounded up the top picks for 2025.

Here are some of the best-reviewed cookie cutter sets for 2025:

  1. Ann Clark Christmas Cookie Cutter Set – A high-quality stainless steel set with classic holiday shapes.
  2. Wilton Holiday Cookie Cutter Collection – Affordable, colorful, and great for kids.
  3. R&M International Christmas Set – Durable metal cutters with detailed shapes.
  4. Keapaty 18-Piece Christmas Cookie Cutters Set – A variety pack perfect for making assorted cookies.
  5. Sugar Plum Fairy Cookie Kit – A whimsical, themed set for creative bakers.
  6. OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Cookie Cutters – Easy-to-use and comfortable grip.
  7. JOYIN 13-Piece Christmas Cutter Set – Includes a rolling pin for easy baking.
  8. 3D Gingerbread House Cookie Cutter Kit – Build your own edible gingerbread house.
  9. Custom Name Cookie Cutters from Etsy – Personalized cutters for extra festive treats.
  10. Snowflake Stainless Steel Set – Intricate, detailed cutters perfect for elegant cookies.

If you’re looking for cutters that last for years, stainless steel is your best bet. Some top-rated brands include:

  • Ann Clark – One of the most trusted names in cookie cutters.
  • Fox Run – Known for strong, rust-resistant metal cutters.
  • Ateco – Professional-grade stainless steel cutters with sharp edges.

Not all great cookie cutters have to be expensive! Here are a few affordable picks:

  • Wilton Holiday Plastic Cutters – A set of colorful, easy-to-use plastic cutters for under $10.
  • Amazon Basics Cookie Cutter Set – A variety of festive shapes at a budget-friendly price.
  • Dollar Store Cookie Cutters – Simple but effective, these are great for occasional bakers.

You can find Christmas cookie cutters at several online retailers, including:

  • Amazon – A wide selection from budget to premium.
  • Etsy – Great for unique, handmade, and personalized cutters.
  • Walmart & Target – Affordable and widely available.
  • Specialty Baking Stores – Higher-end professional cutters.

Looking for Christmas cookie recipes to pair with your new cutters? Check out this guide on French Cookies for inspiration!

How to Use Christmas Cookie Cutters Effectively

Using Christmas cookie cutters might seem straightforward, but achieving perfectly shaped cookies requires the right techniques. From preparing your dough to ensuring clean cuts, these expert tips will help you make flawless holiday cookies every time.

Preparing Your Dough for the Best Cut-Outs

A well-prepared dough is the key to achieving sharp and defined cookie shapes. Here’s how to set yourself up for success:

  • Chill the Dough – Soft dough is harder to cut and can lose its shape when baked. Refrigerate for at least 30-60 minutes before rolling it out.
  • Roll Evenly – Use a rolling pin with adjustable guides to ensure the dough has an even thickness. This helps your cookies bake uniformly.
  • Flour the Surface – Lightly dust your work surface and rolling pin with flour to prevent sticking. Too much flour, though, can make cookies dry.
  • Use Parchment Paper – Rolling dough between two sheets of parchment prevents sticking without adding extra flour.

Even seasoned bakers encounter challenges when using Christmas cookie cutters. Here’s how to avoid the most common pitfalls:

  • Don’t Twist the Cutter – Press straight down and lift. Twisting can distort the shape of the cookie.
  • Dip in Flour – Metal cutters tend to stick, so dip them in flour before each cut.
  • Cut Close Together – Minimize dough scraps by placing cuts as close together as possible.
  • Use Cold Dough – If the dough gets too soft, place it in the freezer for 5 minutes before cutting again.

Want bakery-quality Christmas cookies? Try these pro techniques:

  • Use a Bench Scraper – Gently lift cut-out cookies with a bench scraper to keep their shape intact.
  • Freeze Before Baking – Place cut-out cookies on a baking sheet and freeze for 10 minutes to prevent spreading in the oven.
  • Bake on Silicone Mats – These prevent cookies from sticking and help them bake evenly.

Perfecting your Christmas cookie cutters technique will result in beautifully shaped, professional-looking holiday cookies. Once you’ve mastered this, the fun part begins—decorating!

Decorating Christmas Cookies with Cutters

Hands decorating Christmas cookies with royal icing
Holiday cookies being decorated with icing and sprinkles

Baking the cookies is just half the fun! Decorating them turns simple cookies into beautiful, festive treats. Whether you prefer traditional icing or creative embellishments, here’s how to make your holiday cookies stand out.

Royal Icing vs. Buttercream: What Works Best?

The type of icing you choose depends on the look and texture you want:

  • Royal Icing – Perfect for detailed designs, it dries hard and smooth. It’s ideal for creating intricate snowflakes, Santa faces, and Christmas trees.
  • Buttercream Frosting – Softer and creamier, it’s great for spreading and piping but doesn’t dry as firm as royal icing.

For intricate designs, go with royal icing. If you want rich flavor and a softer bite, buttercream is your best bet.

Christmas cookie cutters aren’t just for cutting dough—they can help with decorating too! Try these creative techniques:

  • Stencil Method – Place a cookie cutter on a baked cookie and dust powdered sugar or cocoa inside for a stencil effect.
  • Icing Borders – Use cutters to trace icing outlines before filling in colors.
  • Sprinkle Guides – Fill the cutter with sprinkles over a cookie for a neat, contained design.

Creative Decorating Ideas for Holiday Cookies

Want to wow your friends and family? Try these fun and festive ideas:

  • Metallic Accents – Use edible gold or silver dust for a luxurious touch.
  • Marbling Effect – Swirl different colors of royal icing for a unique, artistic look.
  • Layered Designs – Stack smaller cookies on top of larger ones for 3D effects.
  • Candy Embellishments – Use crushed candy canes, mini chocolate chips, or festive sprinkles for added texture.

For more holiday baking inspiration, check out this guide on French cookies!

DIY Christmas Cookie Cutter Ideas

If you’re feeling creative, why not try making your own Christmas cookie cutters? DIY cutters allow you to create custom shapes and bring unique designs to life. Whether you’re crafting cutters from scratch or using household items, these ideas will help you get started!

Creating homemade cookie cutters is easier than you think! Here’s what you need:

  • Aluminum strips – Easily bendable and perfect for shaping.
  • Tin snips or heavy-duty scissors – For cutting the aluminum.
  • Pliers – To shape and smooth the edges.
  • Super glue or a stapler – To secure the ends together.

Step-by-Step Guide:

  1. Draw Your Shape – Sketch your desired design on paper to use as a guide.
  2. Cut the Aluminum Strip – Measure and cut the strip to match the shape’s outline.
  3. Shape the Cutter – Use pliers to bend the aluminum along the sketched design.
  4. Secure the Ends – Staple or glue the ends together, ensuring a sturdy hold.
  5. Smooth the Edges – File down any rough areas to prevent injuries.

Now, your homemade Christmas cookie cutter is ready to use!

No cookie cutters? No problem! You can still create festive Christmas cookies using common kitchen items:

  • Drinking Glasses – Perfect for round cookies, great for decorating as ornaments or snowmen.
  • Butter Knives – Carefully cut out shapes by hand for a custom touch.
  • Foil Molds – Shape aluminum foil into stars, hearts, or bells for a temporary cutter.
  • Cardboard Templates – Trace a shape onto sturdy cardboard, place it on the dough, and cut around it with a knife.

DIY solutions allow you to craft unique holiday cookies without spending extra money. Plus, they’re a fun way to get the whole family involved in baking!

Christmas Cookie Cutter Maintenance & Storage

Taking care of your Christmas cookie cutters ensures they last for years. Whether they’re metal, plastic, or custom-made, proper cleaning and storage will keep them in top shape for every holiday season.

How to Properly Clean Metal and Plastic Cutters

Cleaning your cookie cutters correctly prevents rust, bacteria, and dough buildup. Follow these tips:

  • Hand Wash Only – Metal cutters should never go in the dishwasher. Wash them with warm, soapy water and dry immediately.
  • Use a Toothbrush for Crevices – Scrub small corners to remove stuck dough or icing.
  • Sanitize Plastic Cutters – Plastic cutters are generally dishwasher-safe, but check the manufacturer’s instructions.

For stubborn dough, soak cutters in warm water for a few minutes before scrubbing.

Storage Tips to Prevent Rust and Damage

Proper storage keeps Christmas cookie cutters organized and rust-free. Try these methods:

  • Store in an Airtight Container – This prevents dust and moisture from causing rust.
  • Use Silica Gel Packs – Place a small pack inside the container to absorb moisture and keep metal cutters dry.
  • Hang Cutters on Hooks – If you bake frequently, hanging cutters keeps them easily accessible.
  • Stack Plastic Cutters Separately – Avoid crushing delicate shapes by keeping them in separate compartments.

Investing a little time in cleaning and storage ensures your favorite Christmas cookie cutters stay in perfect condition for years of festive baking!

Fun Uses of Christmas Cookie Cutters Beyond Baking

Cookie cutters aren’t just for making cookies! Christmas cookie cutters can be used in creative, fun, and unexpected ways that go beyond the kitchen. Whether you’re looking for craft projects, holiday decorations, or even ways to make meal prep more festive, these ideas will inspire you.

If you love DIY projects, Christmas cookie cutters are perfect for crafting. Here’s how you can use them:

  • Homemade Christmas Ornaments – Trace festive shapes on cardstock, felt, or clay to make beautiful tree decorations.
  • Festive Gift Tags – Cut out paper or fabric using cookie cutters and attach them to gifts for a personal touch.
  • DIY Stamps – Dip metal cookie cutters into paint or ink and press onto paper for unique holiday wrapping paper.
  • Holiday Candle Molds – Pour melted wax into a cookie cutter on parchment paper, let it set, and remove for a handmade candle.

Crafting with cookie cutters is an easy and affordable way to add a handmade touch to your holiday season.

Christmas cookie cutters can also help create festive presentations for holiday meals and gifts.

  • Sandwich & Fruit Shapes – Use cookie cutters to shape sandwiches, cheese slices, or watermelon for kids’ holiday lunches.
  • Chocolate or Fondant Molds – Pour melted chocolate or roll out fondant into cookie cutters to make decorative cake toppers.
  • Edible Centerpieces – Cut out bread or crackers in holiday shapes to create a fun charcuterie board.

Whether for crafts or food prep, using Christmas cookie cutters creatively makes the holidays even more special!

Frequently Asked Questions About Christmas Cookie Cutters

Baking with Christmas cookie cutters is fun, but many bakers have questions about choosing, using, and maintaining them. Here are answers to some of the most commonly asked questions.

The best material depends on your needs:

  • Stainless Steel – Durable, sharp, and great for precise cuts.
  • Plastic – Lightweight, kid-friendly, and comes in detailed shapes.
  • Silicone – Flexible, easy to clean, and ideal for fondant and soft doughs.

If you want sharp edges, go for stainless steel. If you’re baking with kids, plastic is a safer option.

Yes! Christmas cookie cutters are versatile and work for:

  • Fondant & Marzipan – Perfect for cake decorating.
  • Brownies & Rice Krispies Treats – Cut cooled treats into festive shapes.
  • Ice Cream Shapes – Freeze softened ice cream in a baking sheet, then cut out shapes.

They can be used for savory dishes too, like cutting out festive sandwiches or pancakes.

Sticky dough can ruin the shape of your cookies. Try these simple tricks:

  • Chill the dough – Cold dough holds its shape better.
  • Lightly flour the cutter – A dusting of flour prevents sticking.
  • Use non-stick spray – Lightly spray metal cutters for an easier release.

If your dough is extra sticky, freeze it for a few minutes before cutting.

Looking for personalized designs? Try these online stores:

  • Etsy – Offers unique, handmade custom cutters.
  • Amazon – Wide variety of materials and designs.
  • Baking Supply Shops – Many specialty stores offer custom orders.

Custom cookie cutters let you create one-of-a-kind holiday treats!

This FAQ section covers everything you need to know about Christmas cookie cutters. Now, you’re ready to bake, decorate, and get creative this holiday season! Stay tuned for even more festive baking tips and inspiration.